When do children start to feel envious?

Emotional development right from the start -

Three o'clock in the morning - a baby wakes up and starts crying.
His mother comes in and gives her child a drink. The baby sucks happily on the mother's breast, who looks at the child lovingly and caresses it. The child falls asleep again, safe in the arms of the mother.

Three o'clock in the morning - a baby wakes up and starts crying.
His mother is nervous and irritable because she fell asleep only an hour ago after an argument with her husband. The child immediately tenses when the mother abruptly picks it up. While the child is drinking, the mother stares as if petrified without paying any attention to her child and becomes more and more excited because she has to think of the argument from earlier. The child feels this tension, squirms, stiffens and stops sucking. The mother then abruptly puts the child back in its cot and lets it scream until it falls asleep, exhausted.

These two interactions show what different experiences children can have in dealing with their feelings at a very early age (Goleman, 2002). While the first child learns that his needs and expressions of feeling are taken seriously and reliably satisfied by the mother, the second child is taught that his or her emotional expression is hardly or only negligibly observed by the mother. With regard to the child's emotional development, these everyday interactions between parents and children, repeated over many years, shape the child's inner image of how much he can rely on emotional relationships and the consequences of openly expressing his feelings.

First steps in emotional development

Emotional learning begins in the first moments of life and continues throughout childhood. The clearest steps of emotional development take place in the first six years of life and include the following skill areas, which develop parallel to one another and influence one another:

  • Expression of emotions (non-verbal and verbal),
  • Knowledge of emotions (especially knowledge of triggers for certain emotions in oneself and others),
  • Emotion regulation (internal and external strategies in dealing with emotions).

If one looks at the development of the expression of emotions, the non-verbal expression of basic emotions such as joy, sadness, anger and fear can first be observed in the course of development. At the same time, in the first two years of life, the child learns to recognize emotional and emotion-relevant expressions of the caregiver (e.g. the encouraging voice of the mother) and to react to them (e.g. with a smile). In situations in which the child is on their own, it learns regulation strategies and behaviors right from the start, with which it can calm itself down in stressful situations (e.g. by sucking its thumb or with the help of the cuddly toy).

Linguistic expressions of feeling develop from the age of two and expand the child's repertoire of emotional communication as well as the child's learning and interaction opportunities. Talking about feelings becomes more important with age, although non-verbal expression of emotion does not lose its importance in understanding emotions. By verbalizing emotional experience, the child develops so-called “emotional schemata” based on concrete situations (Ulich, Kienbaum & Volland, 1999), i. H. a steadily growing repertoire of “general knowledge” about typical triggers of certain emotions, which it can apply in new situations. In this way, the child acquires the ability to anticipate emotional situations and reactions in themselves and in others and to act accordingly (e.g. avoid unpleasant emotional situations).

Developing emotional and social skills

In preschool age, the child increasingly learns complex emotions, such as B. Knowing pride, shame, guilt or envy - self-related and social emotions, which require certain cognitive developmental steps and a differentiated understanding of emotions. The development becomes clear in the following step model (Wertfein, 2006):

  1. I am proud that it is my birthday today " - Children between the ages of 4 and 5 know about the emotion pride that it represents a pleasant emotion and therefore use the term synonymously with joy, happiness or enthusiasm.

  2. "I am proud of myself when my mom says that I paint beautifully" - Up to about 7 years of age, children are proud when they have been praised. The presence or immediate response of adults is critical.

  3. "I am proud that I can calculate" - Children from the age of 8 usually give their own reasons why they are proud of themselves. By internalizing the parental feedback, for example, the child gradually develops its own benchmark for its own actions and thus the ability to independently assess its own performance.

As soon as children recognize which feelings are triggered in themselves in which situations, they gradually develop an understanding of the emotions of others. Prerequisites for the development of empathy, i.e. the ability to perceive an emotional situation and to experience feelings on behalf of the person concerned (Friedlmeier, 1993) are above all cognitive factors, such as the knowledge that the observable expression of emotions and the actual emotional experience in social Contexts do not always have to match (Petermann & Wiedebusch, 2003; Saarni, 1999). The development of empathy goes hand in hand with the development of prosocial behaviors and can be described as a process from a self-related perspective in the first year of life, when children are not yet able to differentiate between their own feelings and those of others, to context-related empathy in late childhood, which Enables children to take general living conditions into account in their prosocial behavior (Hoffman, 2000) (see also Table 1).

Table 1: Overview of the development of empathy and prosocial behavior

Stage of development

Age

features

Global empathy

1st year of life

Emotional contagion in emotional situations, no prosocial behavior

Self-centered empathy

2 to 4 years of age

Mixing of own and other feelings, gradual increase in prosocial behavior (initially from the point of view of one's own emotional experience)

Emotional empathy

4 to 6 years of age

Differentiation between one's own feelings and those of others, prosocial behavior from the point of view of the person concerned

Contextual empathy

From approx. 7 years of age

Consideration of different life stories, identities and contexts

The ability to empathize is closely related to the knowledge of so-called "social performance rules", i.e. the knowledge that one can or should hide one's actual feelings in certain social situations. A well-known presentation rule can be illustrated using a thought experiment.

Imagine receiving a lovingly wrapped birthday present from your mother-in-law. Excited and full of anticipation, you unpack it under the expectant gaze of your whole family. - But what a disappointment! You wished for a lamp, but it looks used and doesn't suit your taste at all. How do you react?

Most people would probably be happy to say thank you in this situation and not show their disappointment. Why actually? If you ask school children why they sometimes fake or hide feelings, they give the following reasons (von Salisch, 2000; Wertfein, 2006):

  • to avoid negative effects (e.g. negative mood in the family),
  • to protect yourself from injury and exposure (e.g. to avoid public arguments with your mother-in-law)
  • so as not to hurt the feelings of others (e.g. disappointment of the person giving the gift),
  • to be polite and comply with behavioral norms (e.g. gifts and good intentions should be appreciated).

It is astonishing that three-year-olds already have the ability to willingly control their facial expression and hide their actual feelings from others (Petermann & Wiedebusch, 2003; Banerjee, 1997).

While the knowledge of social rules for the expression of emotions represents the outwardly directed form of emotion regulation, children in emotional situations acquire an inner way of dealing with their feelings from the beginning, the so-called internal emotion regulation. In stressful situations, it can be observed that infants and toddlers regulate their emotions interactively, i.e. with the support of their caregivers. With increasing age the children learn that they can avoid unpleasant situations and feelings (e.g. frustration caused by an inaccessible object) by deliberately diverting their attention or withdrawing. In addition, children experience the effect of self-calming strategies, for example through physical calming (rocking, sucking), in preschool age through calming behavioral rituals (e.g. deep breaths) or self-talk. Finally, children from preschool age also use cognitive strategies, such as mental distraction or reinterpretation of emotion-triggering situations (Petermann & Wiedebusch, 2003).

Emotional development, temperament and socialization influences

On the one hand, the various areas of emotional development are related to other areas of development, in particular cognitive, linguistic and social development. On the other hand, genetically determined differences in temperament (especially the emotionality of the child) as well as diverse socialization conditions (e.g. family environment, experiences with peers, school influences) play a decisive role in the question: How do children learn to deal with emotions? The following figure illustrates the interactions between these factors in emotional development.

Figure 1: Factors of emotional development (modified from Petermann & Wiedebusch, 2003, p. 56)

The graph shows that the ability to regulate emotions is closely related to social relationships outside and within the family. Especially with regard to unpleasant feelings such as anger, sadness and disappointment, the repertoire of regulation strategies is an important resource in dealing with stressful situations and conflicts. Children who cannot focus their attention or who often react with anger and suspicion,

  • have deficits in the interpretation of social situations, e.g. by assuming hostile intentions to others (von Salisch, 2000),
  • therefore tend to be aggressive or socially insecure,
  • show fewer prosocial behaviors and a lower ability to empathize (cf. Wertfein, 2006) and
  • are rather unpopular with their peers and thus impaired in their social development (Petermann & Wiedebusch, 2003; Eisenberg et al., 2000).

Children who, on the other hand, use constructive coping strategies, can flexibly adapt their behavior to new situations and express few negative emotions due to good emotion regulation and low excitability are more popular with their peers and are also considered more prosocial, cooperative and socially competent by teachers and parents (cf.Wertfein , 2006). These relationships between emotional and social skills remain largely stable between the ages of six and twelve (Murphy et al., 2004) and can also have an impact on school success (cf. Petermann & Wiedebusch, 2003).

literature

  • Banerjee, M. (1997). Hidden emotions: Preschoolers' knowledge of appearance-reality and emotion display rules. Social Cognition, 15 (2), 107-132.
  • Eisenberg, N., Fabes, R.A., Guthrie, I.K. & Reiser, M. (2000). Dispositional emotionality and regulation: Their role in predicting quality of social functioning. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 78 (1), 136-157.
  • Friedlmeier, W. (1993). Development of empathy, self-concept and prosocial behavior in childhood. Constance: Hartung-Gorre.
  • Goleman, D. (2002). Emotional Intelligence (15th edition). Munich: dtv.
  • Hoffman, M. L. (2000). Empathy and moral development. Implications for caring and justice. Cambridge et al .: Cambridge University Press.
  • Murphy, B.C., Shepard, S.A., Eisenberg, N. & Fabes, R.A. (2004). Concurrent and across time perdiction of young adolescents' social functioning: The role of emotionality and regulation. Social Development, 13 (1), 56-86.
  • Petermann, F. & Wiedebusch, S. (2003). Emotional competence in children. Göttingen and others: Hogrefe.
  • Saarni, C. (1999). The development of emotional competence. New York: Guilford Press.
  • Ulich, D., Kienbaum, J. & Volland, C. (1999). Emotional schemas and differentiation of emotions. In W. Friedlmeier & M. Holodynski (Eds.), Emotional Development. Function, regulation and socio-cultural context of emotions (pp. 52-69). Heidelberg & Berlin: Spectrum.
  • von Salisch, M. (2000). When children get angry: Emotion regulation in development. Göttingen et al .: Hogrefe.
  • Wertfein, M. (2006). Emotional development in preschool and elementary school age as reflected in the parent-child interaction. eDissertation at LMU Munich, Available here.

Further contributions by the author can be found here in our family handbook

Author

Dr. Monika Wertfein is a qualified psychologist and research assistant at the State Institute for Early Childhood Education

Contact

Corner building north
Winzererstrasse 9
D - 80797 Munich

e-mail


Here you can find part 2 of the series: How can parents promote the competent handling of emotions?

Here you will find part 3 of the series: How can educational professionals promote the competent handling of emotions?